Strategic Priming and Mood Induction influences on Raven task performance
Georgi N. Nikolaev; Orlin Baev
Department of Psychology and Cognitive Science, New Bulgarian University
In two preliminary experiments the influence of mood and strategic priming on performance
on the famous Raven matrices task was measured by using the thinking aloud methodology.
Although the results did not reach statistical significance, differential effects on the usage of
searching vs. exclusion strategy was observed in Experiment 1 and the extent to which
subjects relied on superficial features vs. relations in Experiment 2.
In human thinking research the method of priming is widely used and often generates
surprising patterns of performance without subjects being aware of the manipulation and its
relevance. In the current experiments we explored the possibility for changing both the
strategy employed and focus of processing in the Raven task by varying the preceding task
which constituted the priming manipulation.
In Experiment 1 we examined whether solving a classic “odd one out” task could induce an
exclusion strategy - first removing the inappropriate options - in the following Raven task. We
reasoned that by appropriate priming we can increase the usage of this strategy as compared
to a neutral control condition.
A simple between subject design was used with two levels of the independent variable –
presence of an “odd one out” task before the main Raven task and a control level without
Subjects were tested individually in sound proof booths by the second experimenter. They
were instructed to think aloud and verbalize their thought process as they go along the
problems. First all of them were given a practice task that was supposed to accommodate
them to the uncommon in everyday life practice of thinking aloud. Following that procedure,
half of the subjects were given three pictorial tasks such as:
Which is the odd picture from these?
1. saw 2. axe 3. hammer 4. tree
The remaining half proceeded directly to the Raven task, which consisted of three matrices of
medium difficulty. Verbal protocols of the procedure were collected.
10 NBU students volunteered to participate in the experiment. They were split equally in the
two conditions and were rewarded nothing but unforgettable experience.
Results and discussion
After conducting the experiment, we coded the protocols using three categories – a random
strategy, a search strategy and an exclusion, or odd one out strategy. Since the random
strategy was rarely used and not really relevant to out study, we conducted T-tests to
determine the significance of our results using only the search and odd one out strategies:
Although some specific trends were observed in the usage of the Odd-one strategy, our results
remained insignificant. We believe this was caused by the small number of subjects and the
usage of only one coder, and that if we increase the number of subjects to 30 and use two
independent judges for greater validity, our results could show the predicted pattern.
In experiment 2 we used three other matrices from the Raven stimuli, which were chosen
because of being rich in both details and relations.
The same simple one-factor between-subjects design was used. This time we had no control
level. The two levels of the IV were positive and negative mood and our DV was the amount
of statements focusing on details vs. relations.
Our hypothesis was that in a positive mood subjects would tend to ignore the difficulty of the
task and focus on the easily detectable superficial features while in negative mood they would
rely on a more relationally-oriented strategy.
The principal difference with the procedure of Experiment 1 was the priming task. Subjects
we asked to describe one of their best/worst days vividly and describe it to the experimenter,
as well as briefly record it in written form. After a very short delay they were given the Raven
11 university students participated for no payment. Six were in the positive priming condition
and the remaining five in the negative priming condition.
Results and discussion
We used only two pre-determined coding categories - features and relations.
Again as in Experiment 1 the expected patterns of performance was observed without
obtaining statistical significance. We tend to attribute that fact to the small number of
participants. Even if the coding of the protocols was unreliable because of the insufficient
number of coders, we still believe that the predicted pattern is genuine and could be verified
by using 30 or more subjects.
In two short thinking aloud experiments we observed the influence of different kinds of
priming on subsequent intellectual performance. This is the place to make the remark that
none of the total of 21 subjects expressed any suspiciousness during the procedure and
nobody reported any conscious impact of the priming task on their target task performance.
It would be interesting to merge the two experiments into a more complicated factorial design
and observe the possible interactions between the factors. Before that, however, we have ideas
for replications of the current designs using more subjects, coders, and importantly – eyetracking
technology to aid us in the data acquisition process.
- Начална страница
- Групи, Работилници
- Естествена Психотерапия - същност, структурни принципи
- Естествена Когнитивно Поведенческа Психотерапия
- Естествена Хипнотерапия
- Естествена Трансперсонална (Висинна) Психотерапия
- Естествена Психотерапия на Паническо разстройство, Генерализирана тревожност, Вегетативно соматоформна дистония
- Естествена Психотерапия на Социофобия (Социална тревожност)
- Естествена Психотерапия на Обсесивно компулсивно разстройство, Хипохондрия, Конверзионно р-во
- Естествена Психотерапия на Заекване
- Естествена Психотерапия - Сексуалност, Партньорски Отношения
- Естествена Психотерапия на ЗАВИСИМОСТИ
- Естествена Психотерапия - Общество
- За автора на Естествена Психотерапия
- Разкази; Вдъхновяващи текстове
- Orlin Baev
- Моят сайт: http://orlin.bravehost.com Казвам се Орлин Баев. Професионално се занимавам с психотерапия. Това е моята професия и тя съвпада с моето призвание! Обичам природата, планината, морето, безкрая. Мечтая за един свят населен с осъзнати хора, вибриращи в ритъма на любовта, мъдростта и истината!
неделя, 5 декември 2010 г.
Моят сайт: http://orlin.bravehost.com Казвам се Орлин Баев. Професионално се занимавам с психотерапия. Това е моята професия и тя съвпада с моето призвание! Обичам природата, планината, морето, безкрая. Мечтая за един свят населен с осъзнати хора, вибриращи в ритъма на любовта, мъдростта и истината!